Returning profits to shareholders through buybacks and
dividends accounted for 95 percent of all earnings in 2014. As a result, each
additional dollar of corporate earnings now translates to under 10 cents of
reinvestment, according to a study by J.W. Mason of the Roosevelt Institute. This
explains why business investment is at record lows. It’s because the bulk of earnings is being
recycled into buybacks, over $2.3 trillion dollars since 2009 to be precise. Corporations
no longer look for ways to grow their businesses, expand operations, hire more
employees or improve productivity.
Instead, they look for the quick fix, that is, load up on debt, buy more
shares, goose the stock price, and walk away with the loot. Last year,
companies spent $553 billion to repurchase outstanding shares, just short of
the record $589.1 billion in 2007. Large companies like Apple, General Motors,
McDonald’s, Pfizer, Microsoft and more have engaged in buybacks in recent
years. Buybacks are driving the stock
market higher. Corporations purchase buybacks with credit. The level of
corporate debt relative to the size of the economy… is now at its highest level
ever. As corporations have borrowed more and more money, the level of corporate
debt relative to the size of the economy has continued to increase. As the
chart below shows, this ratio is now at its highest level ever — even higher
than it was in 2007, before the last debt-fueled economic implosion.
Importantly, corporate net debt — the amount of debt that corporations are
carrying minus the cash they have on hand — is also at its highest level ever
as a percent of the economy. Those stock prices are a bubble and that a
significant stock market shakeout could leave some of biggest corporations
teetering towards insolvency.
The Wall Street Journal explains:
“Companies are increasingly turning to accelerated share
repurchase agreements…to return cash to shareholders and secure an immediate
boost to per-share profits…..But these turbo-charged stock buybacks can
backfire, especially when a steep market plunge—such as the 5.3% drop in the
markets over the past two trading days. That’s because a steep plunge in stock
prices can force the companies to potentially pay more to buy the shares
through an ASR than what they would pay if they purchased the shares over time
on the open market.
“Things can go wrong,” said Robert Leonard,
head of specialty equity transactions at Citigroup Inc…
Michael Hudson is a distinguished research professor of
economics at the University of Missouri, Kansas City. His latest book, which we
promise to unpack in detail very soon, is Killing the Host: How Financial
Parasites and Debt Destroy Global Economy. He explains:
Companies are under pressure. The managers are paid
according to how well they can make a stock price go up. And they think, why
should we invest in long-term research and development or long-term
developments when we can use the earnings we have just to buy our own stock,
and that’ll push them up even without investing, without hiring, without
producing more. We can make the stock go up by financial engineering. By using
our earnings to buy their own stock. So what you have is empty earnings. You’ve
had stock prices going up without corporate earnings really going up. If you
buy back your stock and you retire the shares, then earnings per shares go up.
But all of a sudden the whole world realizes that this is all financial
engineering, doing it with mirrors, and it’s not real. There’s been no real
gain in industrial profitability. There’s just been a diversion of corporate
income into the financial markets instead of tangible new investment in hiring…
… The job of the Federal Reserve is to increase the price of
wealth and stocks and real estate relative to labor. The Federal Reserve is
sort of waging class war. It wants to increase the assets of the 1 percent
relative to the earnings of the 99 percent, and we’re seeing the fact that
this, the effect of this class war is so successful it’s plunged the economy
into debt, slowed the economy, and led to the crisis we have today…. when the 1
percent lose money, they scream like anything, and they say it’s the job of the
99 percent to bail them out.